Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Ultimate 32 Bit Ct4780

The constitutional revision of 2008: some items modified


Constitutional Revision
of 2008

In his speech of July 12, 2007 in Epinal, Nicolas Sarkozy had expressed his desire to modernize the French institutions by reforming the 2008 constitution, which was one of the promises made during the 2007 presidential campaign.

He then put this promise into effect, creating the committee Balladur, Edouard Balladur compound (UPM), Daniel Canepa (Prefect of Paris from the 1st November 2008), Jean-Claude Casanova (economist), Jacques Julliard (historian and columnist for the new observer), Gerard Longuet (UMP senator) Elizabeth Lulin, Pierre Mauroy (Senator PS), Jean-Ludovic Silicani (Councillor of State), Andre Vallini (PS member and chairman of General d'Isere PS), Dominique Perben (UMP) and Michel Verpeaux (Professor of Law public in Paris I).

It is interesting to observe that the constituent power embodied by this committee (which is derived because it only revise the constitution and does not propose another) was not elected by popular election mass (like the constituent power which General de Gaulle had benefited), while for the establishment of the 4th republic, the people had been consulted by referendum to grant authority to the constituent assembly members at the time.

This committee (prestigious incidentally) was to propose a text of institutional reform, and here are the main changes: [The following items are those which have been the subject of an explanation on this blog spring, they are not all modified, EA]

Article 12:

It is not changed provision in Article 12 between the previous constitution and the current one. Thus, the president retains the right to dissolve the National Assembly under the same circumstances and the same consequences:

The President of the Republic may, after consultation with the Prime Minister and the Presidents of the Assemblies, pronounce the dissolution of the National Assembly.

General elections are held at least twenty days and more than forty days after the dissolution.

The National Assembly meets on the second Thursday following its election. If this meeting takes place outside the period for the regular session, a session is called by right for a period of fifteen days.

It can not be carried further dissolution in the year following the election.

Article 16:

A paragraph was added to the previous article (which provided conditions for the implementation of the exercise of these powers as if where territorial integrity is threatened, for example): it has this: "After thirty days of the exercise of emergency powers, the Constitutional Council can be seized by the president of the National Assembly, the president of the senate or 60 deputies and 60 senators in order to examine whether the conditions set out in the first paragraph remain in place. It is pronounced in the shortest possible time by a public notice. It proceeds from right to review and decide on the same conditions after 60 days of exercise special powers at any time beyond this period. "

Thus, the special powers exercisable by the President of the Republic are more controlled, because certainly the president can still take this authority after consulting the chairman of the national assembly, senate and the Constitutional Council ( which are only consultations is not binding on the president of the republic, ie can not prevent it from having that power) but there is a priori control of the Constitutional Council which can then review the situation and see if the president himself has not violated the constitution, which is a change from former Article 16.

Article 49 paragraph 3 :

This article has been changed in any of those provisions, the following new paragraph 3 of Article 49:

Prime Minister, after deliberation by the Council of Ministers, liability the Government before the National Assembly vote on a bill finance or financing of social security . In this case, project is considered adopted unless a censure motion, filed within twenty-four hours, was voted as provided in the preceding paragraph. Prime Minister may also use this procedure for another project or a bill per session. [Entry into force on 1 March 2009]

Prime Minister may request Senate approval of a policy statement.

This article previously allowed a text to be adopted without a vote, but this possibility is limited by the possibility of deposition of a motion of censure (within 24 hours anyway).

This new paragraph thus gives an opportunity for the Senate to express its opinion with respect to the government (if it decides the course): So the Senate replays again a role in establishing the government accountability.

Section 89 :

Section 89 has changed in any of its provisions, and it has always the following:

The initiative revision of the Constitution belongs jointly to the President of the Republic on proposal of the Prime Minister and members of Parliament.

The draft or proposed revision must be reviewed in terms of time set in the third paragraph of Article 42 and passed by both assemblies in identical terms. The revision shall be final after approval by referendum.

However, the proposed revision is not submitted to referendum where the President of the Republic decides to submit to Parliament convened in Congress and in this case, the proposed revision is approved only if it meets the three-fifths majority of the votes cast. The office of the Congress is that of the National Assembly.

No procedure of revision can be initiated or continued when interfered with integrity territory.

The republican form of government shall not be subject to revision.

this article is that the constitution was revised in 2008, and specifically through parliament: the qualified majority of three fifths of the votes cast.

Further revisions were adopted following the reform, here's a summary:

1. A parliament strengthened somewhat:

Since the inception of the Constitution 50 years ago, civil society has significantly changed the political life as well. It was time to adjust to these institutional changes. That is why institutional reform put in place several measures to strengthen the legislative power

• The Government will no longer be the sole master of the agenda of the meetings. He will share this power with Parliament.

• The role of parliamentary committees will be upgraded: the bills will be considered Sitting in their version passed in committee and not in the original version of the Government.

• The Government should inform Parliament of armed interventions abroad within three days and obtain its approval if the assistance is extended beyond four months.

2. An executive somewhat limited:

• The presidential term will be limited to two successive.

• Parliament can veto (or a majority of 3/5ème in committee) on the most important appointment of the Head of State.

• The right of collective pardon of the President of the Republic is abolished.

• Ministers from Parliament automatically find their seat in the event of resignation or removal.

• The President of the Republic shall preside over the Superior Council of Magistracy (which gives the council and judges greater freedom and greater independence important, even if the President Republic has the prerogative to appoint some members of the CSM).

Moreover, President of the Republic will have the opportunity to speak before Parliament convened in Congress , his statement may give rise out of his presence, in a debate without a vote.

3. Citizens more streamed:

• "Defender of Rights" can be entered by users of a public service if they feel aggrieved.

• Citizens can now seize the Constitutional Council if, in the proceedings, they shall apply to a law they say does not conform to the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution is the exception to unconstitutionality.

• A citizens' initiative referendum can be organized if it is initiated by 1/5th of Parliament and supported by 1/10th of voters (admittedly, the referendum seems very difficult to implement compared to countries neighbors such as Italy, but is part of a political compromise between right and left, and is still some progress).

• The new accessions to the EU will be ratified by referendum (unless the meeting 3/5ème each require ratification by parliament).

• Regional languages belong to the "national heritage" of the nation .

In conclusion, we can say that with this constitutional transition, French institutions have been modernized, and in the interest democracy, although many of compromise does not yet constitute a breakthrough, we can say that there is some offsetting rebalancing the first tendency toward which Nicolas Sarkozy, namely presidentialization regime.

Remi Decombe

To view the full text of the review

0 comments:

Post a Comment